Saturday, March 8, 2014

What is Art?

The title asks What is Art? There really is no answer of course. At least no single answer, and even a set of answers which try to pin down something half definitive would just lead to more discussion and argument. We all know that art and craft are different, but then what of high-end craft? I think we regularly think of artisan one-of-kind ceramics, for example, more art than craft.

There is one definition that has rung true for me over the years. David Pye wrote several books in the late sixties which I bought, because I was learning wood tuning and David did some very interesting turnings. In his book The Nature and Art of Workmanship David lays out a scholarly dissertation (published by Cambridge Press) on the distinction between objects made with an element of risk, and objects made that are completely determined from the start.

The distinction isn't between mass produced items and handmade items, rather, the distinction is between how the process is carried out. Is there an element of chance, risk, or some step in the process that isn't fully determined from the start. Mass produced items must be fully determined in order for production to be efficient. Turning pots or making any craft item can also be fully determined from the start in order to produce items which the public can afford... ditto for 'art'.

I'll let David speak for himself....

Workmanship of the better sort is called, in an honorific way, craftsmanship. Nobody, however, is prepared to say where craftsmanship ends and ordinary manufacture begins. It is impossible to find a generally satisfactory definition for it in face of all the strange shibboleths and prejudices about it which are acrimoniously maintained. It is a word to start an argument with.

If I must ascribe a meaning to the word craftsmanship, I shall say as a first approximation that it means simply workmanship using any kind of technique or apparatus, in which the quality of the result is not predetermined, but depends on the judgment, dexterity and care which the maker exercises as he works. The essential idea is that the quality of the result is not predetermined, but depends on the judgment, dexterity and care which the maker exercises as he work. The essential idea is that the quality of the result is continually at risk during the process of making; and so I shall call this kind of workmanship 'The workmanship of risk : and uncouth phrase, but at least descriptive.

What I pick up on in his definition is that it is not the object itself which is categorized, but the process. This idea of risk in your work intrigued me years ago and still does today.

Beauty isn't art. Beautiful things are mass produced every day. Design isn't art. Design is a process whereby we typically want a predictable end. I've spent a lot of time (as can be seen in past blog posts) thinking about design. I love design. I love to make beautiful things, but for me at least that's not art. It is following a recipe. You use the principles and elements of design and you end up with something pleasing. With a little practice anyone can follow a recipe, and maybe improve on it too.

This post came about  because I was looking through some of my old sketch books. The image at the top of the post is from a period many years ago where I was working with ink, markers and pens. Mostly black and white. Quite the opposite of what I'm doing today. In those days everything was undetermined. I would pick up discarded things laying in the street, cut stuff out of magazines, combine drawings from different places, whatever. Anything that caught my eye was potential content. For example, at the bottom of the above drawing is a bunch of glue globs and whole pieces of wheat.  There's a feather in the middle and on top a discarded pack from Kertek cigarettes. Why?... who knows.

Is it art, or, is my more recent work of abstracted pastoral barns and trees art?

I think it is only worth asking... when I'm done with a piece am I surprised by what was created? How much of the process was out of my control (that is, who/what/how was control applied). What risks did I take in the creative process? Where did I push into a new direction? Am I just repeating myself?

These types of questions probe into the creative process, constantly seeking to make it motivationally authentic, more exciting, more challenging, and leave questions of art for others.


  1. Godly Apex Thanks for sharing, Good Appreciable Thanks for sharing, Good-humoured Appreciation Thanks for sharing, Good-natured Appropriate Thanks for sharing, Graceful Architecure Thanks for sharing

  2. Feasible Sensible 123 HP Envy 6252 Printer Support Thanks for sharing, Felicitous Sentence 123 HP Envy 5661 Printer Support Thanks for sharing, Festive Sight 123 HP Envy 7644 Printer Support Thanks for sharing, Filial Site 123 HP OfficeJet Pro 8710 Printer Support Thanks for sharing

  3. We support all types of HP printer troubleshooting and service. Just enter the model number of your printer in to identify the software and drivers your printer requires. Download and install it in your mac and 'Run' the file. The process is easy however if you have any doubts or queries regarding HP printers contact us.

  4. As with all other printers, 9010 needs basic setup and installation. The connection may be a wired or wireless network in this hp setup.

  5. I am a technical writer based in Tampa, USA and I have been writing blogs on many technical products that have impressed me so far. When it comes to streaming, I have explored a lot of devices. But I have never come across a product like Roku. It is fabulous and more dynamic in design. The shape resembles a Pendrive yet it could bring you loads of Entertainment. The features of the Roku player are pretty decent and especially the enhanced voice search is what impressed me the most. The search provides me almost every movie that I like
    My blog: create account activate account account activate activation enter code setup code
    Roku com link
    Roku com link create account
    Roku com link activate account
    Roku com link code
    Roku com link enter code
    Roku com link activate code
    Roku com link account
    Roku com link activate
    Roku com link activation
    Roku com link setup
    activate Roku com link
    activate Roku com link code

  6. Get Roku and stream unlimited movies and series. Connect your Roku to the TV using the wi-fi or ethernet cable and simultaneously create a Roku account and the enter the unique pin in website. Once activated, head to the Channel Store and pick your choice of entertainment. code
    Roku link code
    Roku enter code
    Roku activation code account create account
    How to activate Roku
    How to set up Roku
    Roku activation

  7. The entire setting up, downloading and installing procedure would be so easy for you when you visit The team has made so easy to download HP printer software to setup your printer.